Game Pass Titles That Deserve a Sequel

2 February 2026

Let's be honest. Xbox Game Pass has become the Netflix of video games — a buffet of digital delights that keeps our backlog growing faster than we can play through it. From big-budget bangers to hidden indie gems, Game Pass has something for everyone. But here's the thing: some of these games were so good, they left us wanting more. A lot more.

Not every game needs a sequel, but let's face it — some stories are too good to end after one entry. Some mechanics are too fun not to expand on. And some worlds are just begging for us to come back. So today, we’re diving into a list of Game Pass titles that absolutely, without a doubt, deserve a sequel.

1. Hi-Fi Rush – A Rhythm-Based Encore, Please!

First off, let’s talk about the surprise hit that took 2023 by storm — Hi-Fi Rush. Coming seemingly out of nowhere, this rhythm-based action game from Tango Gameworks was a breath of fresh air.

You’re Chai, a wannabe rockstar with a music-infused heart literally beating to the rhythm of the world. It’s a fever dream of cel-shaded visuals, punchy combat, and a killer soundtrack… and you can't help but nod your head to every riff and combo.

But when the credits rolled, we just weren’t ready to say goodbye. A sequel could explore deeper beat-matching mechanics, bigger stages, and co-op rhythm chaos. Imagine jamming with a friend in a neon-drenched boss battle. Yeah, that’s the sequel we’re craving.

2. The Outer Worlds – Expand the Universe Already

Obsidian’s The Outer Worlds is often called “Fallout in space,” but honestly, it’s more than that. It’s a quirky, satirical space RPG with colorful characters, morally murky choices, and a wild sense of humor.

Even though it technically got a smaller expansion, we want a full-blown sequel with more planets, deeper faction politics, and new companions to fall in love with (or betray, no judgment).

Obsidian has already teased The Outer Worlds 2, but hey — we're still waiting. The original set the foundation. Now it's time to build a galactic empire of storytelling on top of it.

3. Sunset Overdrive – Bring Back the Chaos

If you missed out on Sunset Overdrive, let me put it this way: imagine Tony Hawk got mixed up in an energy drink apocalypse and started blasting mutants with a shotgun while grinding power lines.

Sounds insane? It is. And it’s glorious.

Insomniac’s cult classic is vibrant, irreverent, and just pure fun in a way that so few open-world games manage to be. Sunset City is screaming for a second round of chaos, even if Sony now owns Insomniac. If there’s a multiverse where Sunset Overdrive 2 exists, I want to live in that timeline.

4. Ryse: Son of Rome – A Gladiator’s Comeback

OK, hear me out. Ryse: Son of Rome caught a lot of flak when it first came out. Yeah, it was a bit shallow gameplay-wise, but visually? It was ahead of its time. And the Roman setting? Criminally underused in gaming.

Ryse had the bones of something great — brutal melee combat, an intense story, and cinematic flair to spare. With a bit more depth in the mechanics and a bolder narrative, a sequel could be the “Gladiator” of video games we’ve been waiting for.

Let’s give Marius Titus the comeback tour he deserves.

5. Quantum Break – Time for a Second Chance

Remedy Entertainment's Quantum Break was a fascinating experiment. Merging a high-concept time-travel story with a live-action TV show? Bold. Maybe a little too bold. But the game had serious potential.

Jack Joyce’s time-warping powers were thrilling in action — freezing bullets midair or reversing explosions never gets old. The performances were top-tier, and the world-building was just starting to get spicy when the credits rolled.

Remedy nailed it later with Control, but I can’t help but feel that Quantum Break deserves a second shot. Give it tighter pacing, more interactivity, and ditch the episodic TV structure. The concept is gold — it just needs some polishing.

6. ReCore – Reboot the Core

ReCore had heart. Built on the dream of Metroidvania exploration mixed with fast-paced robot buddy combat, it had all the right ingredients. But it was clearly rushed to market, and the final product felt like a first draft.

Still, the bond between Joule and her Corebots had that special something. With better polish, more varied dungeons, deeper upgrade systems, and a richer world map, a ReCore sequel could be a sleeper hit.

Call it a second chance. Or better yet, call it ReCore: Fully Charged.

7. As Dusk Falls – More Stories to Tell

Few games tackle narrative storytelling quite like As Dusk Falls. With its unique art style and multi-generational tale of crime, family, and redemption, this game proved that narrative choice still has plenty of room to grow.

But we’re not done yet. The ending left doors wide open for spin-offs, or even direct sequels with new characters in the same universe. What if we explored another family’s trauma? Or rewound the clock to see the same events from different eyes?

Think of it as the “Detroit: Become Human” of Game Pass — and that’s high praise.

8. Tell Me Why – A Follow-up Worth Telling

Created by Dontnod (the minds behind Life is Strange), Tell Me Why follows twins Tyler and Alyson as they unravel a personal mystery from their childhood in rural Alaska. It’s poignant, emotional, and deeply human.

What makes it special? Representation, for starters. Tyler is one of the first transgender protagonists in a major game — and his story is treated with maturity and grace.

A sequel could follow up their lives post-reunion, or spotlight a new story with different characters in the same thematic universe. We need more heartfelt, grounded stories — and Tell Me Why proved there’s an appetite for them.

9. Pentiment – A Narrative Deep-Dive Deserving a Chapter Two

Obsidian again (they’re really killing it on Game Pass, huh?). Pentiment is unlike anything else out there — a historical mystery adventure drenched in the aesthetics of medieval manuscripts.

It’s slow, intellectual, and incredibly rewarding — like reading a really good novel with a magnifying glass. It's not for everyone, but if you're into rich, character-driven stories set in unusual periods, Pentiment is pure gold.

The biggest surprise? How emotionally involved you get. It’s the kind of game that lingers in your mind weeks after playing. With another time period, another monastery, and another mystery? Sign me up.

10. The Gunk – More Muck, Please

Yes, it’s called The Gunk, and yes, it’s better than you think. This charming little third-person adventure sends you to a polluted alien world where you suck up slime (aka “the gunk”) to restore nature and uncover a mysterious civilization.

It’s short, sweet, and visually delightful — like Luigi’s Mansion meets No Man’s Sky. But just as the world starts getting interesting, it ends.

What if we got a bigger budget sequel with more exploration, more upgrades, and deeper environmental storytelling? Expand the universe, double down on the clean-and-conquer gameplay, and let’s make cleaning up the galaxy fun all over again.

11. Carrion – A Monstrous Sequel in the Shadows

Flip the script. In Carrion, you’re not the hero — you’re the monster. A fleshy, crawling terror straight out of a sci-fi nightmare. Your job? Escape the facility, devour scientists, and grow more grotesque by the minute.

It’s reverse horror at its finest. But sadly, it’s over far too soon. The mechanics had plenty of room to evolve — what if the sequel added shape-shifting forms, stealthier infiltration, or even rival monsters?

Carrion 2: Evolution, anyone? We’re hungry for more.

12. Somerville – A Quiet Story That Needs More Noise

Launched with little fanfare, Somerville was an atmospheric, haunting journey through an alien invasion told entirely without dialogue. Think Limbo meets War of the Worlds — and you’re not far off.

It’s minimalistic, emotional, and artsy in all the right ways. But it leaves so much unexplored. Who were the invaders? What do they want? Was that ending hopeful or heartbreaking?

There’s room to answer those questions — or, better yet, raise new ones. Maybe from another survivor’s point of view. Maybe in another part of the world. With such a strong foundation, the possibilities are endless.

So, What Makes a Game Sequel-Worthy?

Let’s not forget — not every game needs a sequel. Some stories are best left where they ended. But every title on this list shares a common trait: they left a spark.

Whether it was a creative gameplay hook, a gripping narrative, or just a lovable cast that felt like friends, these games made a mark. And when gamers connect with something on that level, it's only natural to want more.

Game Pass has become a treasure trove of innovation — and it's high time some of these buried gems got the spotlight again.

Final Thoughts

We get it. Making sequels isn’t easy. Budgets, time, studio politics — all of it plays a role. But if any devs or publishers are lurking out there, hear us out: We’re not just asking for more of the same. We’re asking for evolution.

Take what worked, fix what didn’t, and give us a second helping. Because in a library as rich as Game Pass, the games that stand out? They deserve a second act.

Let us know your favorites — which Game Pass titles do you think are screaming for a sequel?